Wednesday, May 28, 2008

The circle is now complete

From Alice Bradley, a story of how she lost her son to the dark side with, you guessed it, the sinister help of his father.
In the living room, my husband and son are killing each other. "Zat!" cries Henry. "Zat zat zat! I got you with my lightsaber!" "But I am your faaather..." Scott gasps, clutching his stomach. It's too late. Henry, 5, has gone over to the dark side. There's a lot of killing going on in our house. Most of the carnage occurs on Saturday mornings, although occasionally there's time for a duel or two before school.
To say that the story of a child becoming deeply obsessed with Star Wars because of indoctrination from a parent rang true for our household is an understatement. Remove the frustrated mother, replace her with someone complicit and change son to daughter and you have our experience. Why just last weekend an army of children all ages were running around our house with lightsabres saying "prepare to die" and me revealing to three of them that "I am your father. You know it to be true." And yes, we had more than enough lightsabres to go around (adults included)!

I suspect the story is a very familiar one. Parents love Star Wars as children and can't wait to introduce their own to the whole thing. For us, we lucked out that the prequels rocked around so that our eldest could see the last two in the movies (and yes, she was like 4 for Attack of the Clones but she has terrific tolerance for violence and bad dialogue). That mean freely available Star Wars toys in the shops. There were light sabres (even plush ones for babies), action figures, ships, talking Yodas and interactive R2D2's, little Russian doll style toys, clothes and dress-ups galore (including one awesome Darth Vader mask -- and let me tell you, you ain't seen nothing until a 5 year old wearing one of those comes around a corner. Scary and funny at the same time), Mr Potato Head (you know Darth Tater), children's books (including a Pop-up one), video games, and, of course, the wonder that is Star Wars Lego. With parents for whom this was virtual religion, we could say goodbye to spare cash.

Now the way to story is supposed to go is one of grave disappointment. You know, the kids never really care and the parents are forlorn. But no. Just as in the Bradley household, our children took up the cause. For our eldest daughter, it took her away from the year that was the Wizard of Oz (let me tell you, you don't want to open that can or worms with a 3 year old) and into a full blown Star Wars obsession. Dueling was a continual activity and my daughter could recite Weird Al's "The Saga Begins" by heart. There was constant movie watching as she realised that like some Jedi-mind trick, we could never deny her Star Wars like we could normal television. Much to my surprise, the obsession actually became too much. But here is the dismay part -- almost completely focussed on the new movies. How much Jar Jar could we take? (And by the way, those were the cheapest toys of the bunch). But it passed and they moved on.

So this experience is a cautionary one. You can indoctrinate your children with your own childhood obsessions. But it can go too far. And it is, I guess, somewhat fleeting. A few years later you are left with a house full of Star Wars stuff, used and non-collectible and a child singing Hanna Montana songs. It really isn't the best of both worlds.

Saturday, May 24, 2008

Another use for eBay

OK, so don't tell me that you have never been tempted to do what these German parents did; put their baby up for sale on eBay. The ad read:
"Offering my nearly new baby for sale, as it has gotten too loud. It is a male baby, nearly 28 inches (70 cm) long and can be used either in a baby carrier or a stroller".
The only mystery is why they restricted themselves to a positive reservation price. In my mind, the optimal arrangement would be renting. Just a little peace.

The ad was pulled and the police are now baby-sitting the 7th month old. As it is clearly a joke, I guess the parents really got the rental option. If the police had taken the child in temporary custody for show, they might find a queue of willing participants.

Friday, May 23, 2008

Combat activities

A couple of weeks ago I discussed by 9 year old's Taekwondo experiences. I noted that she (and it turns out I to some extent) enjoyed watching some actual fighting going on. But I also mentioned that my 7 year old son was also taking these classes. However, is motivation is somewhat different.

My son is not taking Taekwondo because he enjoys sport. He doesn't, unless of course it is on a computer or video game console. He is taking it because his mother thinks that he is small and that a boy's playground experience at school is full of fighting and that unless he can defend himself he will be clobbered. Now she formed this opinion not on observing boys' playground behaviour now or when she was at school. Instead, it appears to have come from popular culture -- probably, The Simpsons. When I, as a person who had experienced playground boy behaviour, queried this motivation, I was ignored. Apparently, I didn't know what I was talking about.

Now why did I query all of this. Well, I figured that arming our son would not be enough. He would have to want to actually use his skills. What is more, getting picked on can occur but it seemed to me unlikely that actually stepping up was going to deter would be bullies. Better to rely on strategic avoidance such as staying within eyesight of a supervising adult. I myself survived to adulthood and beyond based on this strategy.

The upshot of this is that he was enrolled in classes at age 5 and after a year of this, finally, was allowed to give it up. It just wasn't him. My son would be classed as the sort of person who "wouldn't hurt a fly." Actually, looking at him do his classes, I came to the opinion that he in fact, "couldn't hurt a fly" even if he would want to. That would require speed and force; two factors that were not apparent in his martial arts arsenal. While other kids enthusiastically kicked and punched bags. He would step up and just go through the motions. This eventually convinced his mother that it wasn't to be.

After my last post on this subject a concerned and knowledgeable person emailed me to make sure that I emphasised that the idea that you teach kids Taekwondo so they can actually defend themselves is not correct. Instead, there is a danger of too much confidence and more trouble. All that sounds plausible to me.

Nonetheless, my son had given up for a year and what do you know, some other kid took a swing at him in the playground. And what happened? He used his Taekwondo defensive moves to block the attack! Then he assumed some aggressive looking stance and the other boy ran off.

Well, you can guess what happened next. His mother seized upon this and asked him if he wanted to return to his classes. He said yes and he has been back ever since.

That said, I still think flies have little to fear. In his grading, he is a consistent C student and his in-class enthusiasm is as lacklustre as ever. But that is except for one area: defense. There he scores an A and is the top of his class.

[PS: Any would be Taekwondo and martial arts experts who want to chime in on the comments about the merits of all this, please feel free. I am just relating the story not advocating such classes.]

Sunday, May 18, 2008

It is so unfair

[HT: Greg Mankiw] From P.J. O'Rourke a quote:
I have a 10 year old at home, and she is always saying, “That’s not fair.” When she says that, I say, “Honey, you’re cute; that’s not fair. Your family is pretty well off; that’s not fair. You were born in America; that’s not fair. Honey, you had better pray to God that things don’t start getting fair for you.”
Like Greg, I have had pretty similar conversations although except for the America bit. That said, it is so unfair that we can't buy an official iPhone here in Australia.

Thursday, May 15, 2008

Something doesn't add up

In Slate, Emily Bazelon describes her attempts to keep her 5 year old son calm while teaching him self-reliance. Each Friday, after school, for logistical reasons, her son was not picked up but played a little soccer. He expected and was given a snack (Veggie Sticks) but repeatedly couldn't retrieve them from his own bag and became uncontrollably upset.

Now we have all seen over-reactions in young kids. Out of frustration they panic. But it is usually a once-off. For Bazelon it was repeated and, indeed, she had not resolved it by the time she came to write the article.

I was left with the impression that we only had half the story. First of all, it may be that other children were getting 'better' snacks. Would it really be the case that he would have so much trouble finding a snack if it were a treat rather than Veggie Sticks? If it was my kids, put a treat in their bag and it would likely never make it to the end of school.

Second, what were the supervising parents doing? It seems strange that each week they couldn't resolve the situation.

Finally, if my kids are anything to go by, by the end of the week they are quite ratty and tired. The last thing they would want is a lesson in self-reliance.

My thought is: it's Friday, lay off the life lessons and if you have to be late, put a treat or something special in his bag.

Sunday, May 11, 2008

A Poem for Mummy

On Mother's Day we have a rule: no one spends any money. Thus, the children spend time making things. This year, our 9 year old outdid herself by writing a poem. I thought I'd post it here. Suffice it to say, it says quite a bit about the author.

AN ANNOYING PERSON

One day a mother dug in a book,
but then her head went up and looked.

"Is there anything I can do for you?"
"Because I really need to do a poo."

The mother just looked up and said,
"JUST KEEP ME READING ON MY BED!"

"Ok then I'll go do my poo,
but I really want to do something for you."

"Alright, alright go do your poo,
and then I'll give you something else to do."

"Ok, ok now I'm back,
but I really need to feed my cat."

"Please I'm really really waiting,
alright alright, I'll do some painting."

"Do you like my lovely picture?"
"It's great for the subject of literature."

"Be quiet! By quiet you're annoying me now!"

"Ok, ok I'm going down."

Yes, it is derivative of Dr Seuss but as the author says, she didn't have to make up any words. I think it has more in common with Madeline myself.

Pay Equivalents for Home

In celebration (re: exploitation) of Mother's Day, salary.com released a calculator of how much pay mothers would get it their home duties received market-level compensation. Try the calculator here. And just to be sure, there is a 'Dad' version too that gives rise to exactly the same results.

And where do such magical figures come from? Well according to the news report:
The eighth annual survey calculated a mom's market value by studying pay levels for 10 job titles with duties that a typical mom performs, ranging from housekeeper and day care center teacher to van driver, psychologist and chief executive officer.

... The biggest driver of a mom's theoretical salary is the amount of overtime pay she'd receive for working more than 40 hours a week. The 18,000 moms surveyed about their typical week reported working 94.4 hours — meaning they'd be spending more than half their working hours on overtime.

Working moms reported an average 54.6 hour "mom work week" besides the hours they spent at paying jobs.

So the methodology is seemingly sound. If you had to replicate the parent's work with outside paid labour, how much would it cost you? Notice that the salary.com calculation is the cost of complete outsourcing of parental tasks (save for playing with your children or really quality time). It even includes the overall management component with a CEO function. (I wonder if that includes stock options?). That said, it has all to do with averages and what is more, the average value of work in the house seems to exceed average outside the home earnings which, makes our definitions of national income really dubious.

And so how might you use this information? For one, you could use it to work out whether a parent carrying out these functions should stop and themselves work outside of the the home. Suppose that the annual pay (after tax) from this is w, then you need to also figure out what the increment to your overall utility (re: happiness or satisfaction) would be working outside versus working at home (including all of the satisfaction you get from control in your parenting and the annoyance you get from lack of control in your career and so on). Call this v. Note that v may well be negative implying that all monetary considerations aside you actually prefer working at home to your best option outside of the home.

Then the calculation as to whether you should stay at home is if the salary.com figure exceeds v + w. If it does, stay at home. If not, outsource the home stuff and go out. (In principal, if you want to take some leisure time rather than do the home stuff you will need to work out the value of that and substitute it for w.)

What this wont tell you is which parent should do what task? That depends on individual expertise and satisfaction from each task. Good luck sorting that one out using numbers!